Archive for May 2008
dialectics in doggerlands
I walked out in the garden with De Kooning this morning. It was mild and no longer raining. There wasn’t much wind.
‘A good day for cycling,’ I said.
We looked into Hugo’s world. The plastic moose stood exactly where we had first sighted it, steadfast, implacable, and totemic. The heron still tilted at the gurgling pool. The henge was tranquil. We wondered if Maureen and the gangling boy had been given the opportunity to survey all this and to ask Hugo the question about Intelligent Design. The station clock said it was almost ten o’clock.
When we went back into the house Margaret was wrapping some things in a sheet of lilac and pink Paisley patterned paper. She told me it was Brenda’s birthday.
‘Ah,’ I said, knowingly, ‘the fifth day of May. What have you got for her this year?’ I would also have liked to have asked how old Brenda is now, but I knew I wouldn’t have been told.
‘A antique silk Liberty scarf, a Chakra pendant and a bottle of a really good Chateauneuf du Pape.’
Now to me a birthday is just another day. Whatever interest I had in celebrating it dwindled to almost zero when I became an adult. If there is to be a yearly ritual marking aging perhaps it ought to be a wake of sorts, or at least a sombre stocktaking exercise to look at what you’ve done in the last twelve months and what there’s left for you to do before the reaper makes his inevitable and perhaps quite unexpected appearance. Momento mori would be a good focus for a birthday. A birthday party that denies death is to me a wasted opportunity.
But this isn’t a philosophy Brenda Blenkinsopp subscribes to. Brenda is a girl who expects her friends to recognise how special she is in the only way that a true friend can – with a debit card. Being a life coach and steeped in new age anti-materialism, she does not of course say that the price and quality of the gifts she gets matters one jot. Not at all. In fact Brenda will say she subscribes to the proverbial position that it’s the thought that matters. However, experience has clearly suggested that the thought that doesn’t elicit the right kind of gift will not be counted as a thought at all, or at least not one of the kind that matters. A detailed analysis of Brenda’s responses to the gift objects she has received over the years suggests that a gift generated by a thought that matters will be one that makes a clear and accurate statement to the world about her very particular qualities. The gift will confirm that Brenda has class, that she is creative and cultured, and that she is a beautiful, remarkable person. To date no cheap gift has managed to make this statement properly. It is therefore a reasonable hypothesis that expenditure is a reliable indicator of the quality of the thought that matters to Brenda. Further evidence of this hypothesis lies in the fact that a few years ago Margaret was away on business in Chipping Norton and wasn’t able to get Brenda a present. Margaret rang Brenda from the hotel on the morning of her birthday to explain and to say that she hoped she had a marvellous day. It was almost seven months before Brenda spoke to her again. Ever since then Margaret has expressed her thoughts with much greater care.
‘Have you put my name on the card?’ I asked.
‘Of course.’
I took my bike up to Cresswell and rode the Castles and Coast route up along Druridge Bay through Amble and into Warkworth. Vague wraiths of mist were drifting up from the beach as the sun broke through. The sea was calm and steel blue. As I sat eating an apple at Low Hauxley I saw group a sand martins flickering and flirting around the edge of the dunes. Most years martins and swallows arrive before the end of April and always before I hear a cuckoo, but this group is the first I’ve seen this year even though I heard my first cuckoo more than a week ago now. It felt like summer really had arrived today. Ice cream vans and t-shirts, old men with slow dogs, little girls on pink scooters.
When I got back I sat in the garden for a while and watched De Kooning playing tennis with the bumblebees. The lawn already needs mowing again and is now host to a gaudy crowd of invading dandelions. I might do it after work tomorrow.
Margaret arrived home at about eight. I was watching a Time Team special about archeological remains found beneath the sea, evidence of human activity at a time thousands of years ago when Britain was still connected by a land bridge to mainland Europe. A Dutch investigator had some bones and stone axes from Neanderthal times. The bone was found beneath the North Sea and is about eighteen thousand years old.
‘Did Brenda like her presents?’ I asked.
‘She loved them,’ Margaret replied. ‘We had a really nice time. Her friend Jennifer was there. You remember her, don’t you? Tall willowy blond, works in financial services?’
I shrugged.
‘Oh, you do know her. Oh, and I met Tristan too. He’s a really nice guy. You’d like him too. He’s a Marxist.’
‘Really? That is interesting. So what does a Marxist plumber get for his lady friend on her birthday?’ I asked.
‘Oh, he got her this fabulous blouse and some very, very expensive earrings. Dark sapphires in platinum. He’s also booked them in for a romantic break at a five star hotel in Florence later this month.’
‘I wonder if he isn’t a Trotskyist,’ I said. ‘How are your teeth, by the way?’
‘Actually they’re fine now. I’d forgotten all about them.’
Eighteen thousand years ago there were woolly mammoths, bears and rhinos roaming vast plains in the space where the calm steely North Sea now swills. Archeologists have given this now submerged world the name of Doggerlands. When I googled it I was asked if I meant “diggerlands”. Margaret went off to have a bath. I asked De Kooning if he had ever heard of Che Guevara.
geology, the whelp, and the disembodied heart
Yesterday it was a soft slightly grey morning. I was browsing Amazon, looking at Remembering by Edward Casey. I was also listening to Radio 4. A panel were discussing Boris and his victory in the election. Someone who knows him well was saying he’s a kind of genius, by which he appeared to mean that he’s unique in a uniquely unique sort of way. Boris is clearly not to be regarded as any ordinary man. His acquaintance thought he’d make a good mayor. The door bell rang.
At the door were two Jehovah’s Witnesses. The lead was taken by a very small woman with white hair, large spectacles and a wrinkly puckered mouth. She introduced herself as Maureen. She was wearing a knee length woollen coat of an appropriately ecclesiastical blue. Her colleague was a tall gangling whelp of a boy. Perhaps in his early twenties, he wore black, carried a document case, and had the kind of face that I’ve sometimes seen painted on a peg. He had a pale round face and a little round mouth. He maintained a supercilious expression at all times, part choir boy, part police informant.
‘We’ve come to see if you’re interested in the latest copy of our little magazine,’ Maureen said. ‘You may have seen it before’
I nodded.
She informed me that this latest edition asks the question “Should you fear the future?” and she handed me my copy of Awake! . I smiled. The pitch here is prophesy. They want me to acknowledge the imminent apocalypse and to be afraid, to be very afraid. They want me to buy my ticket to the only safe bunker in town, Kingdom Hall, which last time I looked was a refurbished pebble-dashed pre-war cinema in Newsham.
‘Thanks,’ I said. ‘I’ll give it a read.’
‘It’s terrible what they’ve done to the world, isn’t it?’ Maureen said, and went on to press the predictable buttons of global warming, the environment, the decline of family life, war and the ruination of paradise. I wondered who she thought “they” were, and why she thought “He” had let things go this far. Maybe it’s the past that should scare us most. If God had to put himself up for re-election what could He say He’d achieved so far? The tousled headed cherub-fiend Boris would make holy mincemeat of Him.
She paused. She could see I wasn’t taking the bait. The gangling whelp looked vaguely mesmerised.
‘Do you have a bible?’ she enquired. I said I did. I thought perhaps she wanted to give me one of those too. ‘Well,’ she went on, pointing, ‘ you’ll see I’ve put a scriptural reference at the top right hand corner there. Can you see it?’
I squinted at the magazine. She’d written “PS 37:10,11”.
I smiled again and quietly disclosed to her that I don’t believe in God. She seemed surprised. It was impossible to tell what the gangling whelp’s response to this news was. He just stared at me, like the heron looking into Hugo’s pool.
‘Oh, why not?’ she asked, as if both curious and concerned. I could see no point in getting into a futile argument. I told her I simply never had.
‘Oh, but you don’t believe in evolution, do you?’ she said. Her tone now was a mixture of pity, incredulity and shock, as if she was asking me if I had been molested as a child. Maureen was aghast.
‘Yes, I do,’ I said, whereupon she told me there was no evidence for it and that ‘they’ say it’s been proved to be all wrong. The gangling boy stood as still as a peg, as silent as an undertaker’s apprentice. There isn’t going to be much space in the bunker, I thought to myself. Suppose I got the seat next to him? Meanwhile Maureen was busy suggesting to me that the world as it was couldn’t possibly be the result of chance, that there must have been a designer. I just knew we’d wind up here. I glanced over into Hugo’s junkyard and wondered what she’d say about that. Would she see it as an example of Intelligent Design? But where would that debate take us?
‘You don’t believe in geology, do you?’ I asked. I thought this was a smart move. Maureen was probably imagining me surrendering my reason to the marvellous intricacies of a thousand clockwork finches. Mud and clay on the other hand rarely enter the ID debate as examples of the world’s inexplicable complexity. ‘The world’s been around for millions of years and the evidence is in the ground you’re standing on. As I understand your group’s view, you believe we’ve only been here for a few thousand years. How can that make any sense?’ Yes, I know: ‘group’ was wickedly secular.
At this point Maureen found a way to mention Noah. She then said that the world had been around for a very long time before God created man.
‘Yes, it was about six days, wasn’t it?’ I said.
‘Oh, but you know, the bible doesn’t necessarily mean literally six days.’
She was now a fundamentalist sitting duck. The gangling boy seemed oblivious of the fact that I already had my fowling gun at the ready.
‘If that’s not literally true, then maybe the whole story isn’t literally true either,’ I said. ‘Not Adam and Eve, nor The Flood, nor Christ’s death and resurrection, not the walking on the water or the loaves and fishes, and not even the Apocalypse either.’
Maureen now told me she wasn’t an expert in these things, but that she believed in God and that He had the power save us all. I told her I respected her beliefs but I didn’t share them. The gangling whelp maintained his studious silence. They walked off together down my garden path, feathers still sticking to their coats. Their next stop was Hugo’s world.
I went back into the living room. Margaret had turned off the radio and was watching a cooking programme on TV. I looked at the Napoleon on the mantelpiece. My spirit was less uplifted than I thought it should be.
De Kooning and I sat in the conservatory. I had a cappuccino and he watched the blackbirds coming and going with their beaks full of worms.
* * * * * * *
Earlier today I drove up the Rothbury to go for a walk. It’s a place I used to go a lot, but hadn’t been for a year or two. I took the usual road in, west along the Coquet through Pauperhaugh, below Cragside, on past the Thrum. At the edge of the town I discovered a new road junction has been built and that what was the major road has now become the minor road. I stopped at the junction and on the hillside ahead of me saw some large new houses. Ancient green fields have become a building site and are already well on their way to becoming a substantial new housing estate.
Much of Northumberland is being spoilt this way. This is particularly ironic for a county that markets itself as ‘unspoilt’, an epithet which ceased to be true some years ago now. Towns that once had a distinctive character and a quiet beauty are becoming bland, counterfeit and indistinguishable from one another. And bigger towns need bigger roads and the roads fill up with traffic. Houses fill with people and the people need shops and services, and where there are shops and services yet more new houses are built and more roads to bring more visitors to town. Street lights appear for miles around and night and day the noise of the traffic nags into every dene and over every fell. If you want to see the future go and look at North Tyneside.
Not one of the people I know who lives in one of the many villages and country towns being spoiled this way tells me they want all these new houses. Most say they don’t. But that’s not how our modern democracy works, of course. We no longer cast our votes to decide on the shape of the world we want to live in. We are given the new world first and then vote on whether we like it or not. But by then it’s too late, the green fields have already gone.
The eschatology of the creeping apocalypse obviously doesn’t involve horsemen and dragons. Strategic planning, NGO’s, budget controls, ring fencing, penalties and incentives, planning regulations, planning gain, sham consultations, performance indicators and targets, PFI, exclusivity agreements, the unitary authority, the city mayor . . . these are among the beasts which signal we are in the final days. Little by little ordinary people are disempowered and lose the things that made the world feel like home. The future has already been sold to a private equity company. Some day soon every place will look the same. Most of us will survive, but our lives will be devoid of all happiness.
Margaret’s dream was wrong: the economy is not God’s little clock. The economy is a time bomb. But Field Marshall Gordon doesn’t know it. Night after night he sits nursing what he thinks is the cherished clock of the economy, like a robot holding his own disembodied heart, winding it up over and over again, wishing it would sometimes just tick a little more quickly. It’s a bomb, Gordon – it’s a bloody time bomb! It’s no good, I know: Gordon couldn’t defuse it even if he wanted to. And nor, I suspect, could Major Boris, genius or not.
I walked up on to the carriage drive and looked down on the new housing estates from the crags of Addyheugh. I wondered where Tesco would be putting their supermarket. I wondered where they’d put their filling station. This is how the world ends, Gordon. Bang! Bang! Bang!
A flurry of feathers blows across dark, deserted acres of block paving. The security light flicks on. There’s no-one there.
A minute later the light goes out.
the dilemma of a disillusioned bystander
This morning I could see that Margaret still had unfinished business with me. As I sat watching the early morning TV news she came and sat opposite me. It is the day of the local government elections and I was wanting to see how Boris and Ken were shaping up
‘So what would you do with my clocks?’ Margaret said. ‘What time would you set them at?’
I shrugged. ‘I would have just left them where they were when you got them.’
‘Why?’
‘Why not?’
‘Do you think how they were when they came had some special significance?’
‘No, I think whatever time they tell is meaningless.’
‘So what would be the problem with putting them at different times?’
I could see this was leading me into a contradiction. It was looking as if I was saying that the completely chance combination of times that these clocks constituted after their piecemeal arrival had a particularly meaningful sort of meaninglessness.
‘There is no problem in doing that,’ I said. ‘None at all.’
‘Okay, so what times would you set them at then?’
‘I wouldn’t have moved them from where they were. That would have as much meaning as anything else.’
‘Oh, come on, that’s a cop out. Come on, dip your toe into the universe and play God.’
This was a tight spot for me. We both knew I was playing God already. In this my universe where all the clocks have stopped at random I was refusing to acknowledge my responsibility for the new temporal order. I was a disenchanted, non-interventionist God, a surly deity pretending I wasn’t there at all. I was elevating chance to a transcendental process. I had caught myself off guard. I was momentarily flirting with mystery.
‘I’d remove the hands from every clock,’ I said, ‘Unburden the clocks of their paradox, return them to timelessness.’
Margaret smirked. She put her cup in the sink and went off to work.
I have been in Morpeth all day on a training course. This morning and around midday there were some heavy hail showers, but in the afternoon it became quite warm and bright. It feels like the first day of summer.
When I got home from work I went to cast my vote. Afterwards I went for a walk and reflected on the squabble I’d had with Margaret over her clocks. I could see that the dispute revealed some fundamental differences in our personalities. Later I devised a self-assessment tool, an instrument I have provisionally called The Stopped Clocks Test. The instructions are simple. Imagine you have twenty three clocks, all broken beyond repair, and you have decided to keep them as ornaments in your house. From the following list, choose two options – the first being the one you are mostly likely to follow, and the second the one you are least likely to adopt.
- Remove their hands
- Set them all to midnight
- Never move them from the time at which they stopped
- Set them all at six o’clock
- Set them all at ten to two
- Set them all at twenty past eight
- Set them individually at regularly spaced times throughout the twelve hours
- Set each at a time at which some special event happened to you
- In absolute darkness reset each one randomly
- Set them all at the time at which you were born
- Set them all at the time at which you believe you will die
- Turn all their faces to the wall
There is no time limit for the completion of this test. It is important that it is not completed casually or impulsively. The test can be used simply for self assessment purposes or, where appropriate, for the assessment of the compatibility of individuals within partnerships.
I asked Margaret how her teeth were tonight.
‘How do you think they are?’ she replied.
There are some questions it’s best not to answer.


